Saturday, February 16, 2008

Gara-gara takut Islam

Eropah 'terancam' dengan kehadiran Islam yang semakin berkembang, sementara pengaruh Kristian pula menurun. Baca perenggan yang disorot ini: Catholics are now more worried about the perceived advance of Islam than about maintaining old entitlements for their faith. “Their dilemma is whether the rights which their faith enjoys can be justified when new ones, like Islam, are appearing in Europe.” Some of Italy's Muslims, meanwhile, have been demanding “secularism” in the sense of diluting the Roman Catholic culture of the state, which is epitomised by crucifixes in court rooms, classrooms and hospitals. A Muslim convert, Adel Smith, has been fighting a long battle to get such symbols removed.


Defining the limits of exceptionalism
Feb 14th 2008 THE HAGUE, ROME AND TORONTO


From The Economist print edition
The right of faiths to run their own affairs and regulate their adherents' lives has recently become controversial—because of fear of Islam


AMONG family-law buffs, the case is seen as a key example of the messy ways in which religious and civil law can get entangled. It concerns an Italian couple who wed in a Catholic church in 1962. After 25 years of less-than-blissful union, she got a legal separation from a civil court, which told him to make monthly maintenance payments. But he had other ideas: he convinced an ecclesiastical court that their union had never been valid, because they were close blood relations.

After vain appeals to various civil and religious courts in Italy (to which she complained that she never got a chance to tell her story), she turned to the European Court of Human Rights, which in 2001 ruled in her favour and made a modest compensation award. The European judges in Strasbourg had no jurisdiction over church courts—but they did find that Italy's civil judges failed to assess the religious courts' work or note the deficiencies.

In every democratic and more-or-less secular country, similar questions arise about the precise extent to which religious sub-cultures should be allowed to live by their own rules and “laws”. One set of questions emerges when believers demand, and often get, an opt-out from the law of the land. Sikhs in British Columbia can ride motorcycles without helmets; some are campaigning for the right not to wear hard hats on building sites. Muslims and Jews slaughter animals in ways that others might consider cruel; Catholic doctors and nurses refuse to have anything to do with abortion or euthanasia.

Even in determinedly secular states like France and the United States, the political authorities often find that they are obliged, in various ways, to cope with the social reality of religious belief. America's Amish community, fundamentalists who eschew technology, has generally managed to get around the law with respect to social security, child labour and education. In France, town halls serving large Muslim populations ignore secular principles as they get involved in the ritual slaughter of sheep.

Apart from exceptions to existing laws, another sort of problem arises when religious (and other) communities establish bodies that work very much like courts—and may be called courts—that enforce ancient rules that are often called laws.

All these questions, but especially the last of them, have been on the mind of Rowan Williams, the Archbishop of Canterbury. The Anglican leader caused a furore when he suggested, on February 7th, that some accommodation between British law and sharia, or the Muslim legal tradition, was inevitable and should perhaps be made official.

At first, there seems not to be any huge problem about the existence of institutions whose members freely choose to respect a set of norms—so long as participation really is voluntary, and the rules do not horrify the rest of society. (Intuitively, most Western societies accept the circumcision, on religious grounds, of baby boys, but they would not tolerate the genital mutilation of baby girls.) But in almost every democracy which aspires at the same time to be fair, secular and tolerant of religious diversity, it is getting harder to mark out and preserve the boundary.

Until recently, religions with deep local roots—like Anglicanism in Britain or Lutheranism in Scandinavia—could rely on well-honed survival instincts; clerics had developed a keen sense of how much “soft theocracy” society could accept, and when to beat a tactical retreat. Even the existence of court-like institutions, dealing in particular with marital and property issues, caused little fuss as long as everybody involved recognised the absolute primacy of the law of land. In Britain, for example, religious courts or beth din used by Orthodox Jews have been recognised by statute—and in 2002, divorce law was adjusted in a way that acknowledged the role of these bodies. (If a Jewish husband refuses to seek a religious divorce—thus denying his wife the chance to remarry in a synagogue—a civil judge can now delay the secular divorce.)

The Church of England uses ancient canon laws to govern the use of church property and its internal workings. But like the monarchy, it knows that the way to retain some vestigial authority is to give up most powers that could be controversial.

What has upset the old equilibrium, say law pundits in several countries, is the emergence all over the world of Muslim minorities who, regardless of what they actually want, are suspected by the rest of society of preparing to establish a “state within a state” in which the writ of secular legislation hardly runs at all. The very word sharia—which at its broadest can imply a sort of divine ideal about how society should be organised, but can also refer to specific forms of corporal and capital punishment—is now political dynamite.

That has rendered controversial some things that were once well accepted, like the existence of arbitration services which lighten the burden of the state by providing an alternative arena in which disputes can be settled. As Maurits Berger, a Dutch specialist on Islam and the law, points out, most English-speaking countries have a tradition of dealing with family law through arbitration—voluntary procedures to whose outcome the parties are bound. (Things are different in continental Europe, where the nearest equivalent is non-binding mediation services.)
The Canadian province of Ontario is the clearest case of an English-speaking place where fear of Islam made religious arbitration untenable. An uproar began in 2003 when Syed Mumtaz Ali, a retired Ontario lawyer, said he was setting up a sharia court to settle family law disputes for Muslims. Such arrangements were allowed by the province's 1991 Arbitration Act and could carry the force of law.

The proposal caused an instant backlash, right across the religious and political spectrum; many Muslim groups were opposed too. Marion Boyd, a retired attorney-general, investigated the matter and initially recommended that the Arbitration Act should continue to allow disputes to be adjudicated by religious bodies—subject to stricter regulation by the state. But that turned out not to be good enough for Ontarians who were nervous of sharia. In September 2005 the province's premier, Dalton McGuinty, decided to prohibit all settlement of family matters based on religious principles under the Arbitration Act. Religious arbitrators could still offer services in the settlement of disputes, but their rulings would not have legal effect or be enforceable by the courts. The province's laws were duly changed.

The political background to these moves is no secret: a general wariness of Islam prompted not only by the September 2001 terrorist attacks, but also by NATO's war against the Taliban in Afghanistan, in which scores of Canadian soldiers have died. Moves to establish sharia tribunals, be they ever so voluntary, aroused “quite a lot of anti-Muslim feelings”, says Alia Hogben of the Canadian Council of Muslim Women (which opposed the tribunals). “It allowed people to say, here they come, they are going to ask for more and more.” Apart from a general fear of theocracy, says Jeffrey Reitz, a professor at the University of Toronto, Canadians were nervous that “some of the progress that's been made with gender equality might be lost if we begin to accommodate various group that have less concern...”

As anxiety over (real or imaginary) Muslim demands for sharia turns into a broader worry about theocracy and religious exceptionalism, many democracies are seeing bizarre multi-polar disputes between secularists, Christians, Muslims and other faiths.

In southern Europe, says Marco Ventura, a religious-law professor at the University of Siena, Catholics are now more worried about the perceived advance of Islam than about maintaining old entitlements for their faith. “Their dilemma is whether the rights which their faith enjoys can be justified when new ones, like Islam, are appearing in Europe.” Some of Italy's Muslims, meanwhile, have been demanding “secularism” in the sense of diluting the Roman Catholic culture of the state, which is epitomised by crucifixes in court rooms, classrooms and hospitals. A Muslim convert, Adel Smith, has been fighting a long battle to get such symbols removed.

In France, President Nicolas Sarkozy has dismayed secularists by stressing the country's Catholic heritage in some recent speeches. But the late (Jewish-born) Archbishop of Paris, Cardinal Jean-Marie Lustiger, was a staunch defender of the secular state as a bulwark against all forms of fundamentalism.

Defining the relationship between religion and the state was certainly easier when it could be assumed that religion's hold over people's lives and behaviour was in long-term decline. But with Islam on the rise, and many Christians—even those with the vaguest of personal beliefs—becoming more defensive of their cultural heritage, the line is getting harder and harder to draw. On that point at least, Archbishop Williams was quite correct.

29 comments:

Multifuncional said...

Hello. This post is likeable, and your blog is very interesting, congratulations :-). I will add in my blogroll =). If possible gives a last there on my blog, it is about the Impressora e Multifuncional, I hope you enjoy. The address is http://impressora-multifuncional.blogspot.com. A hug.

bernard n. shull said...

i did a little research after you told me about your "thing", and if you want a way to make more money using your your blog you can enter this site: link. bye.

Anonymous said...

fathi aris ni saya tgk byk yg dia ciplak and bagi keterangan. nak buat tulisan sendiri takda pun..banyak fakta dia yg dia ciplak hehe..sian tah mana bahan yg dia ciplak. leh caya ke dia ni..

Anonymous said...

q29tq64u

oama8orj

f39s020t9d

oxqjdn0v

sazpbycy

Anonymous said...

qfxnt9h4

tk74gd7b

f39s020t9d

w8iydi2x

gir1b9ld

Anonymous said...

who is matt dillon dating http://loveepicentre.com/ dating sussex

Anonymous said...

hanmudo ebook http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/Data-Warehousing-and-Knowledge-Discovery-Second-International-Conference-DaWaK-2000-London-UK-September-4-6-2000-Proceedings/p193791/ ebook read market tool web site [url=http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/it/Electronic-Commerce/p105798/]telecharger ebook oreilly[/url] warriors power of three ebook

Anonymous said...

ebook stop sweating and start living http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/fr/The-Dragonriders-of-Pern-25-Dragon-Harper/p30215/ marketing strategy ebook download porter [url=http://audiobookscollection.co.uk/it/Photoshop-CS3-For-Dummies-For-Dummies-Computer-Tech/p186687/]free autocad ebook[/url] ebook maestro reviews

Anonymous said...

ebook 8086 pdf http://audiobooksworld.co.uk/authors/?letter=X&page=5 drums along the mohawk ebook [url=http://audiobooksworld.co.uk/Culture/c1688/]resistance band ebook pdf[/url] lyle mcdonald ebook
[url=http://audiobooksworld.co.uk/In-Suspect-Terrain/p18844/][img]http://audiobooksworld.co.uk/image/8.gif[/img][/url]

Anonymous said...

windows uml modelling software invisio http://buyoem.co.uk/it/product-37198/Magic-Music-Editor-5-3 dvd recorder software 6.0 revision [url=http://buyoem.co.uk/product-36584/Microsoft-Windows-7-Ultimate-x32-Norwegian]swl software[/url] max msp software
[url=http://buyoem.co.uk/de/category-100-101/Betriebssysteme]Betriebssysteme - Software Store[/url] small business accounting software ratings
[url=http://buyoem.co.uk/de/product-17671/CompareFolders-3-0-Mac][img]http://buyoem.co.uk/image/8.gif[/img][/url]

Anonymous said...

palm treo 750v free software http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/it/product-36779/SQLBackupAndFTP-6-0 website content management software [url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/fr/product-36830/IBM-SPSS-Text-Analytics-for-Surveys-4-0-x64]pages 07 software[/url] bookseller software
[url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/product-16069/Microsoft-Office-2008-Mac]Microsoft Office 2008 [Mac] - Software Store[/url] better branches software
[url=http://buyoemsoftware.co.uk/product-35287/4Media-iPad-to-Mac-Transfer-4-2-MacOSX][img]http://buyoem.co.uk/image/5.gif[/img][/url]

Anonymous said...

winbox software free download http://buysoftwareonline.co.uk/product-24113/BitRock-InstallBuilder-Enterprise-6-0 sim cloning software [url=http://buysoftwareonline.co.uk/it/category-200-210/Internet]winfund software powered by vbulletin[/url] mecury software
[url=http://buysoftwareonline.co.uk/product-14340/Readiris-Pro-11-5-Mac]Readiris Pro 11.5 [Mac] - Cheap Legal OEM Software, Software Sale, Download OEM[/url] best free hacked software movies
[url=http://buysoftwareonline.co.uk/es/category-200-212/Multimedias-y-entretenimiento][img]http://buyoem.co.uk/image/2.gif[/img][/url]

Anonymous said...

[url=http://redbrickstore.co.uk/products/lisinopril.htm][img]http://onlinemedistore.com/10.jpg[/img][/url]
advantages and disadvantages of being a pharmacy technician http://redbrickstore.co.uk/products/ampicillin.htm monarch pharmacy [url=http://redbrickstore.co.uk/products/cystone.htm]pharmacy technician books[/url]
zyrtec pravachol foreign pharmacy http://redbrickstore.co.uk/products/suhagra.htm new mexico school of pharmacy [url=http://redbrickstore.co.uk/products/minocin.htm]minocin[/url]
medco pharmacy locations http://redbrickstore.co.uk/products/retin-a-0-05-.htm pharmacy exclusive provider organizations [url=http://redbrickstore.co.uk/products/viagra-super-active-plus.htm]hahnemann pharmacy[/url]
valuim foreign online pharmacy http://redbrickstore.co.uk/categories/women-s-health.htm silagra silagra pharmacy pharmacy cum with us com [url=http://redbrickstore.co.uk/products/azulfidine.htm]azulfidine[/url]

Anonymous said...

Don't put limits on what you eat as much as you do how much you are eating. It is important that you realise that if you do miss one of your exercise sessions it is not the end of the world. t have to starve just because you think eating is making you obese.

Feel free to surf to my blog; fitness tips and workouts
my webpage :: fitness Tips And workouts

Anonymous said...

So, while I am no roving reporter I am endeavoring with my menial reporting skills, to bring you.
Researches have also found the Broccoli also contains necessary enzymes such as myrosinase
in it. All kinds of sports news today are offered live through the television.


My blog; Latest Daily News

Anonymous said...

People talk themselves out of exercising so easily, and the opposite can
be so easy. It will help the prospective health and fitness aspirant keep pace with the ever evolving world of
fitness. Having some company can also make the fitness session more fun.


My weblog :: fitness tips articles

Anonymous said...

Firstly, you must exercise; without proper workout, you
can bid goodbye to your dream of having a flat tummy.
My grandma can really feel vindicated at such
a claim,she's been saying this all my life. The problem is that many do not follow through with their fitness plans and thus fail within the first 3 months of starting a new fitness plan or routine.

my site - visit the following web page

Anonymous said...

Very good post! We will be linking to this great post
on our site. Keep up the great writing.

Also visit my web page just click the next web site

Anonymous said...

A lot of us who are under constant pressure tend to eat too
much and do not take good care of their bodies.

We know because they have done so for millions of other people.
What I tell my clients is that they need to schedule their fitness
time like it's a doctor's appointment.

my web-site - exercise and fitness tips aerobic exercise

Anonymous said...

Learn few fine points of software editing with numerous tutorials that are
simply accessible with few simple clicks. If you have a bad dog, you can submit your story online on this
submission form on baddogs. While wasting your time
watching something marginally funny may actually frustrate you, watching truly hilarious movies and shows
is an easy way to get laughter into your life whenever you need it.


Here is my homepage :: funny pictures at walmart

Anonymous said...

Instead of eating to make yourself feel better find other methods to cope.
It is important that you realise that if you do miss one of your exercise sessions it is not the end of the world.
Take note also that you know how to perform the exercise well to avoid sickness and injuries
in the future.

my blog :: fitness tips abs

Anonymous said...

Helping optimistic people excel - in 7 areas of life is her mission.
Blowing off some steam with a quick round of solo travel fitness in the morning can make your whole day brighter.
What I tell my clients is that they need to schedule their fitness time like
it's a doctor's appointment.

my web-site Skip Navigation

Anonymous said...

pve05d6u

mfcebyri

f54yewr4t536

fa2ic2p2

lsvwkqfu

Anonymous said...

Well, as we know world is changing day by day and its every single move in politics,
business or even entertainment world affects our lives a lot.
I also have to wonder if the evening news shows are more
interested in ratings or in reporting the real news.

They can also update news on their site as and when the event occurs while the
newspapers have to wait until the next morning.

Feel free to surf to my web blog ... Latest Daily News

Anonymous said...

lvkekizc

il87rci6

f54yewr4t536

xnxxt2u4

pr8esho5

Anonymous said...

l0bdjelc

mnqjj15a

f54yewr4t536

r5sov47n

j9eflldh

Anonymous said...

Bring your favorite magazines to the i - Phone with an i - Phone app.
Stay connected with for the latest tit-bits of pick me up news and cool celebrity pictures.
He covers gossip on celebrities, actors and musicians.

Stop by my page :: latest celeb news

Anonymous said...

Bring your favorite magazines to the i - Phone with an i -
Phone app. Stay connected with for the latest tit-bits
of pick me up news and cool celebrity pictures.
She married singer Mark Anthony in2005 and released her next album called Rebirth.



Here is my web page; http://community.onesourcejewelrysupply.com

Anonymous said...

tulsa dating sites http://loveepicentre.com/success_stories/ shemale dating canada
chef dating pelham alabama 33 hockey [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]poetry teen dating[/url] european dating cultures
dallas texas dating [url=http://loveepicentre.com/articles/]profile stian dating[/url] free dating site comparisons [url=http://loveepicentre.com/user/richi/]richi[/url] montreal ukrainian dating